Yes, a commercial lease can give your landlord a share of the money a buyer pays for your business. In California, it happens when a transfer fee clause is written broadly enough to reach more than the lease itself. Many leases require the landlord’s consent to an assignment or sublease, then claim a percentage of any consideration the tenant receives for the transfer. Some set that percentage at 50% or more.

Most business owners never read that clause closely until a buyer shows up. By then the lease is signed, the buyer is waiting, and the landlord holds the consent that the deal needs to close.

What Is a Lease Transfer Fee?

A lease transfer fee clause (sometimes called a profit sharing, excess consideration or recapture of consideration clause) requires the tenant to pay the landlord part of what the tenant receives for assigning or subletting the lease.

In its fair form, the clause addresses a narrow concern. A tenant should not make a profit by subleasing space for more than the tenant pays the landlord. California law allows that arrangement, and Civil Code section 1995.240 says so expressly:

A restriction on transfer of a tenant’s interest in a lease may provide that the transfer is subject to any express standard or condition, including, but not limited to, a provision that the landlord is entitled to some or all of any consideration the tenant receives from a transferee in excess of the rent under the lease.

Notice what the statute does not do. It does not define “consideration,” and nothing in this section limits it to rent. The excess over rent language is one example of a permitted condition (“including, but not limited to”), not a ceiling on what a lease may claim. Nothing in this section automatically confines a landlord’s share to rent, so the only limit is the one written into your lease.

Here is what a narrow clause looks like (illustrative language, not taken from any particular lease):

Tenant shall pay Landlord fifty percent (50%) of any rent or other consideration received by Tenant from a subtenant or assignee for the use of the Premises that exceeds the rent payable under this Lease.

And here is a broad clause (also illustrative):

Tenant shall pay Landlord fifty percent (50%) of any consideration of any kind paid or payable to Tenant or its owners in connection with any assignment, sublease or other Transfer.

The two clauses look similar. They are not. The first reaches only extra rent. The second reaches “any consideration of any kind,” and says nothing about what is excluded.

How a Transfer Fee Can Capture the Sale of Your Business

Two drafting choices turn an ordinary sublease clause into a claim against your exit.

The definition of “Transfer.” Many leases define a transfer to include a sale of substantially all of the tenant’s assets, a merger, or a change in ownership or control of the tenant entity. If your lease does, selling your business triggers the clause even when you sell stock or membership interests and the lease never changes hands on paper. The statute itself defines a transfer of a tenant’s interest as an assignment, sublease, or other voluntary or involuntary transfer or encumbrance of all or part of the tenant’s interest in the lease (Civil Code section 1995.020(e)). It is the lease’s own definition that pulls in a sale of the business or a change of control.

The definition of “consideration.” If the fee applies to “any consideration” with no carve out for goodwill, equipment, inventory or the business itself, a landlord may argue that the purchase price is consideration paid in connection with the transfer. The landlord’s position is that the location is what makes the business valuable, so the landlord should share in that value. Whether that argument succeeds depends on the words of the lease and the facts of the sale. The risk is that the words may let the landlord make it at all.

A hypothetical. Suppose a tenant sells a restaurant for $600,000, including equipment, goodwill and an assignment of the lease. Under the narrow clause above, the landlord collects nothing, because the buyer is paying no rent above what the lease already requires. Under the broad clause, the landlord could assert a claim to $300,000. The tenant often learns this days before closing, when the landlord’s consent is a condition of the deal and the landlord has the most leverage it will ever have.

Practice Tip: Read the transfer provisions when you sign the lease, not when you sell. Negotiating leverage is highest before signature. It is lowest when a buyer’s deadline is running.

What Does California Law Say About Transfer Restrictions?

California’s statute on transfer restrictions in commercial leases begins at Civil Code section 1995.210. A few points matter here.

  • Landlords may restrict transfers. Under section 1995.230, a lease may prohibit transfer outright, and under section 1995.240 it may condition transfer on express standards, including a share of excess consideration.
  • Reasonableness protects the consent, not the fee. Under sections 1995.250 and 1995.260, when a lease requires consent but states no standard, consent may not be unreasonably withheld, and the tenant carries the burden of proving that it was. That rule governs whether the landlord may refuse. It does not rewrite a fee you agreed to in writing.
  • Freedom of contract is the policy. In section 1995.270, the Legislature states that the purpose of this framework is to enable and facilitate freedom of contract in commercial leases.
  • Ambiguity may help, but do not plan around it. Section 1995.220 provides that an ambiguity in a restriction on transfer of a tenant’s interest in a lease shall be construed in favor of transferability. That may help in a dispute. A clearly drafted fee provision is a poor place to hope for it.

The takeaway is practical. California lets landlords and tenants agree to these provisions. The protection you get is the protection you negotiate.

How Do You Know If Your Lease Has This Problem?

You find out by reading the lease the way a landlord’s lawyer would read it after a sale is announced. Work through these steps, and look beyond the section titled “Assignment and Subletting.”

  1. Find every transfer provision. Search for assignment, sublease, transfer, change of control, consent, recapture and profit. These terms often appear in the definitions, the default section, riders, amendments and any guaranty.
  2. Read the definition of “Transfer.” Does it include a sale of assets, a sale of stock or membership interests, a merger, or a change of control? Is there an ownership percentage that triggers it?
  3. Read the fee itself. What is the percentage, and what is it a percentage of? “Rent in excess of the rent under this Lease” is very different from “profit,” “net proceeds” or “any consideration.” Also look for flat administrative fees and reimbursement of the landlord’s attorney fees.
  4. Look for carve outs. Does the clause exclude consideration for goodwill, equipment, fixtures, inventory and other business assets? Does it permit transfers to affiliates, family members and estate planning entities without a fee?
  5. Check the process. Look at the notice period, the landlord’s response deadline, the consent standard, and whether the landlord has a recapture right, meaning the right to terminate the lease rather than consent.
  6. Run the numbers. Plug a realistic sale price into the literal words of the clause and calculate what the landlord could claim. If the answer is uncomfortable, the clause is a problem, whatever anyone says it was meant to do.
  7. Assemble the whole lease file. Confirm that you have the original lease, every amendment, any assignment from a prior tenant and any guaranty. A fee can be added or broadened in an amendment you have forgotten.

Practice Tip: If the lease is silent on any fee, that is useful information. In that case the main question is the consent standard under Civil Code section 1995.260, not a payment to the landlord.

Why You Should Never Rely on Oral Assurances

Landlords, brokers and property managers often say, “We only use that clause for subleases,” or “We have never charged anyone that.” Those statements may be sincere. They are still not protection, for four reasons.

  • The writing controls. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 1856, the terms of a written agreement intended as the final expression of the parties cannot be contradicted by an earlier or contemporaneous oral agreement. Most commercial leases also contain an entire agreement clause that says the same thing.
  • Long leases must be in writing. Under Civil Code section 1624, an agreement to lease real property for longer than one year must be in writing to be enforceable.
  • People leave and buildings sell. The person who made the promise may be gone by the time you sell your business. A new owner of the building takes the lease as written and may never have heard of the promise.
  • Intent is not the test. A landlord who truthfully says the clause was never meant to reach a business sale may still enforce it if the words allow it. That is not bad faith. It is simply what the document says.

So the rule is simple. If the landlord’s intent is that the clause applies only to subleases and excess rent, ask the landlord to write that intent into the lease. A landlord who means what was said should have no objection. A landlord who objects has told you what the clause is for.

How to Fix It Before You Sign or Sell

Before you sign, ask your attorney to negotiate these changes:

  • Limit the fee to a defined “Transfer Premium,” meaning rent or other consideration paid for the use of the premises above the rent you owe, net of your brokerage commissions, improvement costs, free rent and legal fees.
  • State that the fee does not apply to consideration paid for your business, goodwill, trade fixtures, equipment, inventory, intellectual property or equity.
  • Remove a sale of assets or a change of control from the definition of “Transfer,” or list them as permitted transfers that require notice only.
  • Delete the recapture right, or limit it to subleases of most of the premises.
  • Set a firm deadline for the landlord’s response and cap the landlord’s review costs.

If you already have the lease, raise the issue before a buyer appears. Ask the landlord for a written amendment that fixes the language, and offer something in exchange, such as a longer term or a larger security deposit. A side letter or an email from a property manager is a weaker fix than a signed amendment, so insist on the amendment.

If a sale is already in progress, bring the landlord to the table early. Ask for a written consent, an estoppel certificate and an express waiver of any transfer fee. In the purchase agreement, make that waiver a condition to closing and decide in advance who pays any fee the landlord does collect.

If you are the buyer, include the transfer provisions in your due diligence. A fee the seller owes today can become a dispute at closing that delays the deal.

Practice Tip: Do not treat a lease review as a formality. A lease built from a standard form can carry a costly clause in a paragraph nobody highlighted. A careful read, with your exit in mind, takes a fraction of the time that a dispute would.

Key Takeaways

  • A broadly drafted transfer fee clause can give a landlord a share of what a buyer pays for your business, not only extra rent from a sublease.
  • Two definitions decide the risk: what counts as a “Transfer,” and what counts as “consideration.”
  • California law permits transfer fee provisions (Civil Code section 1995.240), nothing in that section limits “consideration” to rent, and the reasonableness rules govern the landlord’s consent, not a fee you agreed to.
  • Do not rely on what a landlord or broker says the clause is meant to do. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 1856, the written lease controls.
  • Fix the language before you sign, or before a buyer appears, with a signed amendment that limits the fee to excess rent and excludes the sale of your business.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a landlord take part of the sale price when I sell my business in California?

It depends on the lease. If the transfer fee clause defines a transfer to include a sale of the business and applies to “any consideration,” a landlord may claim a share. If the clause reaches only rent above what you pay under the lease, it should not. The words of your lease decide.

What is a commercial lease transfer fee?

It is a payment the tenant owes the landlord when the tenant assigns or subleases the lease. It is often a percentage of the consideration the tenant receives, and some leases set it at 50% or more.

Does California law limit how much a landlord can charge for a lease transfer?

California law allows a lease to condition a transfer on express standards, including a landlord’s share of consideration the tenant receives above the lease rent (Civil Code section 1995.240). The statute does not set a percentage and does not limit “consideration” to rent, so the result is largely a matter of what the lease says.

Can I rely on my landlord’s promise that the clause will not apply to my sale?

No. An oral promise cannot contradict a written lease that is the parties’ final agreement (Code of Civil Procedure section 1856), and a new owner of the building may not honor it. Get the change in a signed amendment.

When should I have an attorney review the transfer provisions?

Before you sign the lease, and again before you list your business for sale. Early review gives you the most room to negotiate.

If you lease space for your business, or you are thinking about buying or selling one, the transfer provisions in the lease deserve a close read before they matter. The attorneys at Branfman Mayfield Bustarde & Reichenthal, LLP review commercial leases and handle small business sales for owners across North County San Diego. Contact BMBR in Carlsbad to schedule a consultation.

This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on your specific situation, consult a qualified attorney.